Opens in a new tab
Free calculatorFor accounting and bookkeeping practices

Practice software requirements scorecard: choose a client and job tracking tool in 20 minutes

Answer seven questions about the tool you use now to see the must-have it fails that matters most. Then get a Word demo checklist and an Excel weighted scorecard to compare up to five options in 20 minutes.

  • Your result on screen, no email needed
  • Email only for the file
  • No phone number

How it works

  1. Answer a few questionsTakes a few minutes
  2. See your resultOn screen straight away
  3. Get the fileAdd your work email and it downloads

0 of 9 answered

Does your current tool put a due date and one named owner on every client job?

Answer for the tool or tools you use today, including any spreadsheet. Pick the option that is true on a normal week.

Do recurring jobs repeat each month, quarter or year without retyping?
Can you see which jobs are done, open or overdue across every client in one view?
Can you track BAS, IAS and payroll steps as jobs, not only tax returns?
Does each client record hold the entity type, ABN, contacts and who acts for them?
Does it connect to your ledger package?
Do you know what it costs for your number of staff and clients, from a written quote?
How many people work in your practice?

Including you. This tailors the result. It does not change the maths.

What does your practice do?
The file

What is in the file

  1. Result: for each option, the weighted score, must-haves failed, must-haves not yet scored and a status, with the option that meets every must-have and scores highest.
  2. Criteria: 20 criteria and five spare rows with a must-have flag, a weight from 1 to 5, and a score from 0 to 5 for each option.
  3. Must-haves: each must-have against each option, showing Meets, Fails or Not scored. Settings holds the option names and the pass mark.
  4. Decide this month and How it works, with an example of five options labelled as an example, scored with placeholders.

Also included: software-requirements-scorecard.xlsx: the Excel weighted scorecard for up to 5 options.

Background

The demo that is all tax returns

You book a demo of a tool that tracks clients and jobs. For forty minutes the vendor shows a tax return moving through review, and you leave unsure whether the tool can hold a monthly bookkeeping job with a BAS and a payroll run in it. You liked the screens. You did not get an answer to the question you went in with.

Write the must-haves before the demo, not after

A scorecard fixes that by moving the decision to before the demo. You write a short list of must-haves, weight them, and ask each vendor to show you each one, using one of your own clients. A tool that cannot show a must-have in a minute scores low on it, however good the rest looks. The Excel scorecard turns those scores into a weighted result for up to five options, and screens out any option that fails a must-have, so a high total cannot hide a gap in something you cannot do without.

The default weights are our starting points, not research. Change them to match your week: a solo bookkeeper and a team of eight will weigh them differently.

Twenty minutes, then decide

The Word checklist runs the 20 minutes: five to write the must-haves and the scenario, ten to watch the demo against the questions, five to score straight afterwards while it is fresh. It names no vendor and quotes no price. For cost, it asks you to get a written quote for your own staff and client numbers and to type the result yourself.

Then the scorecard gives you five decisions to make this month, each with an owner and a date.

Common questions

Before you start

Why must-haves as well as a score?

A weighted total can hide a gap. If an option fails something you cannot work without, the scorecard marks it as failing a must-have, whatever its total.

Where do the default weights come from?

They are our starting points, not research. Change every weight on the Criteria sheet to match your practice.

Does it name or rank any vendor?

No. You type the option names, and the scores are yours. The file names no vendor and quotes no price.

How do I score cost?

Ask each option for a written quote for your own number of staff and clients, then score the cost row from 0 to 5 yourself. The file holds no prices.

Why do you need my email?

So we can send you the checklist and the scorecard. You do not need to be a Sole customer, and we do not ask for a phone number.

Sole Practice Manager

Where Sole Practice Manager fits

Sole Practice Manager is practice management software for Australian accounting and bookkeeping firms. It brings CRM, onboarding and KYC, proposals and e-signature, workflow and recurring jobs, a white-label client portal and BAS lodgement through Standard Business Reporting into one place, and it works alongside Xero and MYOB. Score it on your own scorecard like any other option. The demo practice is open without a sign-up.