Opens in a new tab
Free templateFor accounting and bookkeeping practices

A two-level review standard, checklists and a log that shows the queue and the rework

Answer three questions to see where your review is exposed, then get a two-level review standard, checklists for tax returns and bookkeeping files, a feedback script, and a log that counts each reviewer's queue and rework by preparer.

  • Your result on screen, no email needed
  • Email only for the file
  • No phone number

How it works

  1. Answer a few questionsTakes a few minutes
  2. See your resultOn screen straight away
  3. Get the fileAdd your work email and it downloads

0 of 5 answered

Who reviews work before it goes to the client or the ATO?
How do reviewers know what to check?
When a reviewer finds an error, what happens?
How many people work in your practice?

Including you. This tailors the result. It does not change the maths.

What does your practice do?
The file

What is in the file

  1. Team: up to 30 people, each a preparer, a level 1 reviewer or a level 2 reviewer.
  2. Review log: one row per job with the risk tier, preparer, reviewers, stage, first review outcome and rework reason.
  3. Reviewer queue: for each person, jobs waiting at level 1 and level 2, high risk waiting and jobs waiting longer than your limit.
  4. Preparer rework: jobs reviewed, sent back and the rework rate for each preparer, with rework by reason and by job type.

Also included: review-checklists.docx: a tax return checklist and a bookkeeping file checklist; review-log.xlsx: the Excel log with a queue count and rework rate.

Background

The same return, two reviewers

A manager sends a company return back to a graduate with eleven review notes. The same graduate gave a similar return to a different manager last month, and it passed with two. Nobody wrote down what the standard was, so the graduate learned to pick the manager.

The review is the point where the practice decides what good looks like. If it differs by reviewer, the preparer cannot learn it.

Two levels, set by risk

Level 1 is the detail check: the workings, the entries and the checklist, done by a trained colleague who did not prepare the job. Level 2 is the judgement check: the unusual items, the client's circumstances and the summary, done by someone senior. The standard sets which jobs need which levels, so a principal opens the high risk ones and not all of them.

The pack also sets triggers that move a job up a tier, such as a first-year client or a preparer in their first 90 days.

A log turns review into numbers

The review log records each job with its risk tier, preparer and reviewers. The Reviewer queue sheet counts what is waiting for each reviewer at each level, so a bottleneck shows before the week is lost. The Preparer rework sheet shows how often each person's work is sent back, and the reasons, so training goes where it helps.

The feedback script helps the reviewer say what they found in a way the preparer can use. It has four steps: say what you saw, say why it matters, ask what the preparer would check next time, and agree what happens next. Scripts for a first error, a repeated error and strong work are in the pack.

Common questions

Before you start

What do level 1 and level 2 mean?

Level 1 is a detail check against the checklist by a trained colleague who did not prepare the job. Level 2 is a judgement check by a senior person. The standard sets which jobs need both.

Is this suitable for a practice of two people?

Yes. With two people, you may be the only level 2 reviewer, and a colleague does level 1. The standard also covers how to get a second look when the team is very small.

How many jobs and people does the log hold?

Up to 400 jobs and 30 people. For more, keep one copy for each team or each quarter.

Does the pack state what the ATO or TPB require?

No. The checklists are general good practice. Where a rule matters, check the current guidance from the regulator or your professional body.

Why do you need my email?

So we can send you the files. You do not need to be a Sole customer, and we do not ask for a phone number.

Sole Practice Manager

Where Sole Practice Manager fits

Sole Practice Manager is practice management software for Australian accounting and bookkeeping firms. It brings CRM, onboarding and KYC into one place, lodges BAS, IAS and TFN declarations to the ATO through Standard Business Reporting, and works alongside Xero and MYOB. Workflow and recurring jobs hold every client's work and its stage in one list, so a reviewer can see what is waiting. The demo practice shows how that looks.